Verification Log: 01-foundations

One line per disposition, per METHODOLOGY.md §3.6. Format: date · file · claim · disposition · sources.

2026-06-10 — eschatology.md (web-verified citation pass + toll-houses balance rework)

  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Pomazansky Second Coming quote + “Part IV” location · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; real location Part II ch. 10, “Christian Eschatology”) · Orthodox Dogmatic Theology full text (IntraText)
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Gregory of Nyssa work title · Confirmed (De anima et resurrectione; unverified clay-pot ornament removed) · NPNF II/5
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Pomazansky particular-judgment “quote” · Corrected (exact phrase absent; paraphrase + verified “complete blessedness/torment” wording, Part II ch. 10) · IntraText full text
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Isaac the Syrian homily number · Confirmed (Homily 28, Holy Transfiguration Monastery trans.; “punishment of love” wording fixed) · HTM ed. p. 266
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Mark of Ephesus at “Florence 1439” · Corrected (Ferrara 1438; denied purgatorial fire outright, affirmed prayers for departed, referred 1 Cor 3 fire to the Last Judgment) · First Homily on Purgatorial Fire (trans.); standard accounts
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Ware hell quote edition/chapter · Corrected (The Orthodox Church, rev. ed. Penguin 1993, p. 262; 1993 wording; tail converted to paraphrase) · edition check
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Constantinople II anti-Origenist canons · Disputed (structured note: anathemas absent from official acts; Price’s pre-session thesis vs. 543 edict/synod) · Price, The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553, Liverpool UP, 2009
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Theodora / Life of St. Basil the New attribution · Confirmed (disciple Gregory, 10th-c. Constantinople; citation upgraded to Dumbarton Oaks Studies 45, 2014) · doaks.org edition
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · pseudo-Cyril Homily on the Departure of the Soul · Disputed (structured note: PG 77:1074–1090, Homilia XIV De exitu animi; modern scholarship doubts Cyril’s authorship; Orthodox defenders cite it) · PG 77; Shoemaker scholarship
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Chrysostom “various homilies” on departed · Corrected (genuine: Homilies on Philippians 3, NPNF I/13; the “powers of the air” passage is from a spurious consolation homily under his name) · NPNF I/13; pravoslavie.ru
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Macarius of Alexandria homily · Confirmed-with-note (PG 34:385 ff.; Vienna MSS assign to the monk Alexander) · PG 34; manuscript scholarship
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Rose The Soul After Death “chapters 4–6” · Corrected (toll-houses treatment is ch. 6, “The Aerial Toll-Houses”) · book TOC
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · “Archbishop Theophan of Poltava defended toll-houses” · Corrected (no source found; replaced with St. Ignatius Brianchaninov, “Homily on Death,” Works vol. 3, and St. Theophan the Recluse per Rose ch. 6 — apparent confusion of the two Theophans) · negative source check; Rose ch. 6
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · “ROCOR synods in the 1980s endorsed toll-houses” · Corrected (Synod decision Nov 19/Dec 2, 1980: censured Puhalo’s soul-sleep teaching, noted toll-houses in saints’ lives/liturgy, did NOT formally endorse the doctrine, ordered polemics ended) · Orthodox Life 1981/1; orthodoxinfo.com toll-house debate dossier
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Hopko “various lectures” · Confirmed (Illumined Heart interview, Ancient Faith Radio, Feb 22, 2012; 2006 Transfiguration Monastery lecture; position stated in his own words) · ancientfaith.com
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Oxiyuk “toll-houses as pedagogical device” · Apocryphal — claim deleted (the book Eschatology of St. Gregory of Nyssa, Kiev, 1914, is real, but no source attributes the toll-house claim to it) · azbyka.ru/otechnik negative check
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Puhalo book title · Confirmed (The Soul, the Body and Death, Dewdney, BC: Synaxis Press, 1980) · bibliographic records
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Pomazansky toll-houses “quote” · Corrected (invented quote replaced with verified Met. Macarius-of-Moscow caution quote from Pomazansky’s addendum “On the question of the ‘toll-houses’”) · IntraText full text
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · Soul Saturdays “the two before Great Lent” · Corrected (Meatfare Saturday + 2nd/3rd/4th Saturdays of Lent + Trinity Saturday; Russian usage adds Demetrius Saturday) · liturgical calendars
  • 2026-06-10 · eschatology.md · John of Damascus Exact Exposition IV.26/IV.27 (untagged) · Confirmed (chapter titles + NPNF II/9 anchor added) · NPNF II/9

2026-06-10 — theological-anthropology.md, ecclesiology.md, README.md (web-verified citation pass)

  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Maximus image/likeness “Ambiguum 7; Ambiguum 42” · Corrected (image/likeness mapping relocated to Centuries on Love III.25 — being/eternal being vs. goodness/wisdom; logos/tropos distinction kept with Amb. 42 [PG 91:1341C]) · Philokalia vol. 2; Blowers/Constas scholarship on Amb. 42
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Pomazansky image-of-God “quote,” Part II “On Man” · Corrected (quote→verified wording: “man bears the image of God in the higher qualities of the soul…”; real location Part II, “Man — the Crown of Creation,” section “The Image of God in Man”) · full text (Jordanville PDF / IntraText)
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Maximus Ad Thalassium 42 “quote” on transmitted guilt · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; Q.42 confirmed as the locus of the two-senses-of-sin distinction: culpable choice vs. blameless natural corruption) · Blowers & Wilken trans.; scielo.org.za study of Ad Thal. 42
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Chrysostom Homilies on Romans Homily 10 on Rom 5:12 · Confirmed (homily number correct; claim refined to Chrysostom’s actual wording — mortality, not imputed guilt: “became mortal,” “liable to punishment and condemned to death”) · NPNF I/11 (newadvent/ccel)
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · unbaptized infants “no limbo, entrusted to God’s mercy” · Confirmed (citation added: Gregory of Nyssa, On Infants’ Early Deaths, NPNF II/5; diversity-of-opinion note kept as prose) · NPNF II/5
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Pomazansky trichotomy “quote,” Part II “On Man” · Corrected (quote→verified wording: majority of Fathers hold two parts; “spirit” = “the inward and most hidden side of the soul”; section “Soul and Spirit”) · full text (Jordanville PDF)
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Maximus Centuries on Love I.82–86 on the nous · Corrected (I.82–86 concern conceptual images/demons; replaced with I.5–12, e.g. I.8 on fixing the intellect on sensible things instead of God) · Philokalia vol. 2 full text
  • 2026-06-10 · theological-anthropology.md · Yannaras “(b. 1935)” (untagged) · Corrected (Yannaras died Aug 24, 2024; now “1935–2024”) · obituaries (Political Theology Network; orthochristian.com)
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Chrysostom “we are part of him” quote, Hom. Eph. 3 · Corrected (quote→verified wording: “the fullness of Christ is the Church… let us reflect of what a Head we are the body”; Homily 3 confirmed) · NPNF I/13 (newadvent)
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Encyclical of the Eastern Patriarchs “1848” · Confirmed (May 1848; four patriarchs + synods, reply to Pius IX’s In Suprema Petri Apostoli Sede) · orthodoxinfo.com text; standard accounts
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Khomiakov “Church is One” quote, section 1 · Confirmed (§1 correct; wording adjusted to the standard translation: “separate individuality… submitting themselves willingly to grace”) · full text (Antiochian Archdiocese; uoregon)
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Khomiakov “authority of love” quote, “Second Essay” · Corrected (quoted sentence not found in the essay — replaced with verified wording: “The Church is not an authority… The power is found in mutual love”; from the first essay, 1853, trans. Schmemann, Ultimate Questions) · uoregon full text
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · pentarchy as historical reality · Disputed (structured note: Justinian Novel 131 + Quinisext Canon 36 vs. modern scholarship’s “largely theoretical construct,” e.g. ODB) · Oxford Dictionary of Byzantium; Britannica; Chrysos in Margins and Metropolis discussion
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Afanasiev Church of the Holy Spirit publication 1971 · Confirmed (Russian Tserkov Dukha Sviatogo, Paris: YMCA-Press, 1971, posthumous; Eng. trans. Notre Dame 2007) · Cambridge JEH review; UND Press
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Afanasiev “chapters 1–4” for universal-vs-eucharistic argument · Corrected (unverifiable chapter range dropped; argument anchored to “The Church Which Presides in Love,” in The Primacy of Peter, ed. Meyendorff) · The Primacy of Peter (SVS Press)
  • 2026-06-10 · ecclesiology.md · Zizioulas “(b. 1931)” (untagged) · Corrected (Zizioulas died Feb 2, 2023; now “1931–2023”) · obituaries (Living Church; Orthodox Times)
  • 2026-06-10 · README.md · “Claims with lower confidence are marked with [Verify] tags” · Corrected (prose updated to describe the verification pass and its dispositions, with links to this log and METHODOLOGY.md) · this pass

2026-06-10 — pneumatology.md (web-verified citation pass)

  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Maximus Letter to Marinus text · Confirmed (Opusculum 10, PG 91:136; “Father is the one cause of the Son and the Spirit” wording added) · Siecienski, The Filioque, Oxford 2010; bekkos/patristic dossiers
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Gregory of Cyprus Tomos of 1285 title · Confirmed (Tomos of the Council of Blachernae, 1285; “eternal manifestation”/sun-ray simile added from translated text) · Papadakis, Crisis in Byzantium, rev. ed. 1997; trans. of the Tomos
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Filioque at Rome 1014, Benedict VIII / Henry II · Confirmed (first sung at Mass at Henry II’s imperial coronation, 1014, at his request) · Siecienski, The Filioque; standard accounts
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Ephesus “Canon 7” · Confirmed (Canon 7 forbids bringing forward a hetera pistis) · NPNF II/14
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Photius Mystagogy “chapters 67–70” (conciliar argument) · Corrected (§§5, 79–83 in the standard 89-section division) · full text, trans. T.R. Valentine; Farrell ed. 1987
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Mystagogy “chapters 9–18” (two-principles dilemma) · Corrected (§§3–19) · full text check
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Mystagogy “chapters 19–36” (spiration hypostasis/essence dilemma) · Corrected (§§19, 36, 47) · full text check
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Mystagogy “chapters 37–66” (patristic consensus) · Corrected (§§66–89, incl. popes Leo I–John VIII) · full text check
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Mystagogy date “c. 867” (untagged) · Corrected (written late in life, c. 885; 867 is the Encyclical to the Eastern Patriarchs) · Farrell ed.; bibliographic records
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Day of the Holy Spirit pan-Orthodox? · Confirmed (pan-Orthodox Byzantine-rite observance; public holiday in Greece/Cyprus, not specifically Slavic) · Greek calendar sources
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Athanasius Letters to Serapion I.23–24 · Confirmed (1.23 anointing/seal; 1.24 partakers of divine nature; wording adjusted to translation) · PPS 43; scholarly summaries
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · epiclesis “essential consecratory act” claim · Corrected (nuanced per Cabasilas: consecration through the whole prayer, institution narrative + epiclesis as one whole) · Cabasilas, Commentary on the Divine Liturgy 29, trans. Hussey–McNulty
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Florovsky “The Procession of the Holy Spirit,” CW vol. 3 · Apocryphal — no such essay (CW vol. 3 = Creation and Redemption, TOC checked); “Christomonism” charge reattributed to Lossky and Nissiotis; Florovsky bullet rebuilt on “The Catholicity of the Church” (CW vol. 1) · CW vol. 3 TOC; comparative scholarship on Florovsky/Lossky/Nissiotis
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Gregory the Theologian Or. 31.8–9 composite “quote” (untagged) · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; “principle without principle” tail not verifiable in 31.8–9; monarchy point re-anchored to 31.14) · NPNF II/7
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Augustine De Trinitate XV.26.47 “as from one principle” (untagged) · Corrected (unum principium is V.14.15; XV.26.47 gives principaliter from the Father; both now cited) · NPNF I/3
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Basil 18.46, Basil 15.36, John of Damascus I.8 quotes (untagged) · Confirmed (locations verified; NPNF II/8 and II/9 anchors added) · NPNF full texts
  • 2026-06-10 · pneumatology.md · Lossky ch. 3 “quote” on two Trinitarian conceptions (untagged) · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; exact wording unverifiable) · Mystical Theology, ch. 3

2026-06-10 — soteriology.md (web-verified citation pass)

  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Basil “goal of our calling” at On the Holy Spirit 9.23 · Corrected (the likeness-to-God-as-far-as-possible wording is 1.2; 9.23 has “being made like to God… being made God”; both now cited with NPNF wording) · NPNF II/8 full text
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Gregory the Theologian “become gods for his sake” Or. 1, 5 · Confirmed (Oration 1 [On Pascha], 5; fuller NPNF wording restored) · NPNF II/7 (newadvent full text)
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Maximus deification quote at “Ambiguum 7” · Corrected (actual source: Various Texts on Theology 1.62, Philokalia vol. 2, trans. Palmer–Sherrard–Ware — a Byzantine compilation from Maximus’s works; exact Philokalia wording restored) · Philokalia full text
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Palamas Triads III.1.29–33 · Corrected (unverifiable subsection range removed; cited III.1 with Gendle CWS translation) · negative check; CWS ed. 1983
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Gregory Ep. 101 “what is not assumed…” (untagged) · Confirmed (Ep. 101 [First Letter to Cledonius] 32 [SC 208:50]; quote conformed to NPNF wording) · SC 208 citation as used by scholarship; NPNF II/7
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Pomazansky redemption “quote,” “Part III” · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; real location Part II, “The Dogma of Redemption”; book has only Parts I–II) · IntraText TOC
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · “God saves us not without ourselves” as Maximus, Centuries on Theology I.9 · Corrected (misattribution: the dictum is Augustine’s, Sermon 169.11.13 [PL 38:923]; Maximus citation removed, synergy point kept) · PL 38:923 (as cited in CCC 1847); negative check on Maximus
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Constantinople II anti-Origenist condemnation status · Disputed (structured note: anathemas absent from official acts; Price’s pre-session thesis vs. 543 edict/synod) · Price, The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553, Liverpool UP, 2009
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Schmemann “whole liturgical life… sacrament of the Kingdom” quote · Corrected (invented quote replaced with verified “the Eucharist is the entrance of the Church into the joy of its Lord” + paraphrase; ch. 2 confirmed as “The Eucharist”) · For the Life of the World full text PDF
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Khomiakov “we are saved together and damned alone” · Corrected (popular paraphrase; actual text: “when any one of us falls he falls alone; but no one is saved alone,” The Church Is One §9, now quoted with the paraphrase labeled) · full text (uoregon.edu mirror); orthodoxinfo.com
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Lossky deification quote “chapter 9” (untagged) · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; deification treated in ch. 10, “The Way of Union”) · Mystical Theology chapter list
  • 2026-06-10 · soteriology.md · Athanasius De Inc. 54.3, 8–9, 20; Irenaeus AH V pref. (untagged) · Confirmed (PG 25:192B added for 54 per documented citation; NPNF II/4 and ANF I anchors added) · NPNF/ANF; Behr PPS 44a

2026-06-10 — christology.md (web-verified citation pass)

  • 2026-06-10 · christology.md · mia physis formula “derives from Apollinaris” · Confirmed (Apollinaris, Letter to Jovian, transmitted under Athanasius’s name in the Alexandrian archives; Cyril quoted in good faith) · McGuckin, St. Cyril of Alexandria and the Christological Controversy, SVS Press, 2004; pravoslavie.ru scholarly survey
  • 2026-06-10 · christology.md · Constantinople II anti-Origenist canons status · Disputed (structured note: anathemas absent from official acts; Price’s pre-session thesis vs. 543 edict/synod) · Price, Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553, 2009
  • 2026-06-10 · christology.md · Honorius I’s role in Monothelitism · Disputed (structured note: letters to Sergius confess “one will,” anathematized by Constantinople III; Price reads as genuinely monothelite, Catholic tradition after John IV reads as orthodox-in-intent) · Price, Acts of the Lateran Synod of 649, 2014; Catholic Encyclopedia “Pope Honorius I”
  • 2026-06-10 · christology.md · “Opuscule 7” blockquote on the Saviour’s human will · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; the quoted wording is essentially the Constantinople III definition, now quoted as such [NPNF II/14]; Gethsemane treatise identified as Opusculum 6, trans. Blowers–Wilken PPS 25) · NPNF II/14; PPS 25; scholarly literature on Opusc. 6
  • 2026-06-10 · christology.md · Pomazansky “Part III, On God the Son” · Corrected (the “quote” is the Creed, articles 3–5, now attributed to the Creed; Pomazansky location fixed to Part II, “The Incarnation of the Son of God” — book has only Parts I–II) · IntraText TOC

2026-06-10 — holy-trinity.md (web-verified citation pass)

  • 2026-06-10 · holy-trinity.md · Gregory of Nyssa Against Eunomius “I.22–26” · Corrected (unverifiable chapter range removed; cited Book I generally with NPNF II/5 anchor) · negative check; NPNF II/5
  • 2026-06-10 · holy-trinity.md · Synodal Tome of 1351 “quote” · Corrected (quote→paraphrase: light of Tabor neither creature nor essence but uncreated grace/energy; cross-referenced Palamite chapters of the Synodikon of Orthodoxy) · accounts of the 1351 council; Synodikon anathemas
  • 2026-06-10 · holy-trinity.md · Pomazansky essence/energies “quote,” “Part II, On God in Himself” · Corrected (quote→paraphrase; Pomazansky’s knowability treatment is Part I, “Our Knowledge of God,” following John of Damascus, and does not use Palamite “energies” vocabulary) · IntraText TOC; critical commentary on Pomazansky’s dogmatics
  • 2026-06-10 · holy-trinity.md · Bulgakov condemnations “Moscow 1935, ROCOR 1927” · Corrected (Moscow Patriarchate ukaz of Met. Sergius, Sept 7, 1935, teaching “alien” to Orthodoxy; ROCOR Council of Bishops decision Oct 17/30, 1935, declared it heretical; 1936 Paris commission of Met. Eulogius rejected the heresy charge) · rocorstudies.org; OrthodoxWiki/standard accounts
  • 2026-06-10 · holy-trinity.md · Gregory the Theologian Or. 40.41 quote (untagged) · Confirmed (NPNF II/7 anchor added) · NPNF II/7